Lake Plymouth Homes with Colonial Style

Lake Plymouth Homes with Colonial Style

Welcome to Lake Plymouth, a picturesque subdivision nestled in the heart of Stillwater Township, Sussex County, New Jersey. This charming community offers a serene escape from the hustle and bustle of city life, surrounded by the beauty of nature and the tranquility of its namesake lake. With its lush landscapes and vibrant wildlife, Lake Plymouth is an ideal setting for those seeking a peaceful retreat while still enjoying the conveniences of modern living.

One of the standout features of Lake Plymouth is its stunning collection of Colonial-style homes. These timeless residences exude elegance and charm, showcasing classic architectural elements such as symmetrical facades, gabled roofs, and spacious front porches. The Colonial homes in this community are designed with both comfort and functionality in mind, offering generous living spaces and inviting interiors that are perfect for family gatherings or entertaining friends.

Residents of Lake Plymouth enjoy the benefits of a close-knit community, where neighbors become friends and outdoor activities abound. Take a leisurely stroll around the lake, enjoy fishing or kayaking, or simply bask in the beauty of the surrounding woodlands. The subdivision also provides easy access to nearby parks and recreational facilities, ensuring that there’s always something to do.

Whether you’re looking to settle down in a family-friendly environment or seeking a weekend getaway, Lake Plymouth offers the perfect blend of charm, comfort, and community spirit. Discover your dream home in this idyllic subdivision and experience the best of what Stillwater Township has to offer!

Newest Lake Plymouth Homes with Colonial Style

915 Plymouth Lake Dr, Stillwater Twp.
$499,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 4050886 MLS
LAKEFRONT living on beautiful Lake Plymouth! Nestled beneath mature trees in peaceful Stillwater Township, this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath lake-style colonial home offers the kind of setting that makes you want to slow down and stay awhile. Inside, exposed beams and a cozy fireplace add warmth and character, but it's the beautiful lake views from the dining room that truly steal the show. Open the windows and enjoy the refreshing breezes coming off the lake as you dine, relax or entertain with the water as your backdrop. Multiple living spaces provide plenty of room to gather, while the primary bedroom is privately located on the second floor, separate from the two main-level bedrooms. Outside, the deck, patio and lakefront yard invite you to enjoy morning coffee, summer barbecues, quiet afternoons and evenings by the water. Even better, two major improvements are already complete with a NEW ROOF AND NEW SIDING JUNE 2026, along with a NEW RANGE AND NEW REFRIGERATOR DECEMBER 2025. With approximately .34 acre of lakefront property, this is a special opportunity to enjoy the beauty, tranquility and lifestyle of Lake Plymouth while adding your own style along the way. Buyer to independently verify all association fees and related costs. Some pictures have been rendered with AI for visual and illustration purposes ONLY!!!

915 Plymouth Lake Dr, Stillwater Twp.
931 Plymouth Lake Dr, Stillwater Twp.
$599,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 4027605 MLS
LAKEFRONT LIVING AT ITS FINEST! Welcome to this beautifully renovated waterfront retreat on desirable Plymouth Lake, offering breathtaking sunset views, your own private beach, firepit, and year-round vacation-style living. This exceptional home features 3 bedrooms with a 4-bedroom septic, including two spacious lakefront suites with private balconies overlooking the water. The open-concept layout is designed to maximize lake views from nearly every room, while recent upgrades elevate the home throughout, including stunning 6 rift and quartered solid white oak flooring, updated kitchen with stone counters and backsplash, new appliances, fresh paint, and upgraded lighting. Stay comfortable year-round with a newly installed ducted mini-split system, and enjoy cozy evenings by the stone fireplace with pellet stove. Step outside to an expansive deck, brand-new hot tub with gazebo, basketball hoop, and beautifully designed outdoor spaces perfect for entertaining or relaxing lakeside. Additional features include an oversized detached 2-car garage with large floored upper storage area, RV/electric vehicle hookup, generator hookup, upgraded electric panel, exterior camera system, and included boats for endless lake adventures. Located near hiking trails, the Appalachian Trail, shopping, and local attractions. Your lakefront escape awaits!

931 Plymouth Lake Dr, Stillwater Twp.
Start Your Search

The data displayed relating to real estate for sale comes in part from the IDX Program of Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. Real estate listings held by other brokerage firms are marked as IDX Listing.
The information being provided is for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Copyright 2026 Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. All rights reserved.

Updated:


The data relating to real estate for sale on this web-site comes in part from the Internet Listing Display database of the CENTRAL JERSEY MULTIPLE LISTING SYSTEM, INC. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than this site-owner are marked with the ILD logo. The CENTRAL JERSEY MULTIPLE LISTING SYSTEM, INC does not warrant the accuracy, quality, reliability, suitability, completeness, usefulness or effectiveness of any information provided. The information being provided is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify properties the consumer may be interested in purchasing or renting.
Copyright 2026, CENTRAL JERSEY MULTIPLE LISTING SYSTEM, INC. All rights reserved.The CENTRAL JERSEY MULTIPLE LISTING SYSTEM, INC retains all rights, title and interest in and to its trademarks, service marks and copyrighted material.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!